Suggestions by @ry12hu34

Channing Tatum

as Big Barry Syx in Dimension 20 Parties

Phoebe Dynevor

as Chirp Featherfowl in Dimension 20 Parties

Margaret Qualley

as Margaret Encino in Dimension 20 Parties

Regé-Jean Page

as Squak Airavis in Dimension 20 Parties

Hugo Weaving

as Gilear Faeth in Dimension 20 Parties

Taye Diggs

as Antinuous in Epic: The Musical

Carly Rae Jepsen

as Aeolus in Epic: The Musical

Samantha Pauly

as Aphrodite in Epic: The Musical

Ramin Karimloo

as Hephaestus in Epic: The Musical

John Gallagher Jr.

as Apollo in Epic: The Musical

LaChanze

as Hera in Epic: The Musical

Jessie Mueller

as Penelope in Epic: The Musical

Sara Bareilles

as Penelope in Epic: The Musical

Hadley Fraser

as Hephaestus in Epic: The Musical

Reeve Carney

as Polites in Epic: The Musical

Aaron Tveit

as Tiresias in Epic: The Musical

Jasmine Cephas Jones

as Calypso in Epic: The Musical

Andrew Barth Feldman

as Telemachus in Epic: The Musical

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as "Pietro Maximoff" in Wandavision (redo

Teyonah Paris

as Monica Rambeau in Wandavision (redo