Suggestions by @rwhite18

Cillian Murphy

as Actors Who Should Be In The Show in Actors Who Should Be In Carmen Sandiego

Jon Hamm

as Actors Who Should Be In The Show in Actors Who Should Be In Carmen Sandiego

Adelaide Kane

as Actors Who Should Be In The Show in Actors Who Should Be In Carmen Sandiego

Nathan Fillion

as Actors Who Should Be In The Show in Actors Who Should Be In Lethal Weapon

Olivia Cooke

as Dolores Daniels in Shutter Island (2024)

Adelaide Kane

as Phoebe Halliwell in Charmed

Luke Perry

as Dean Winchester in Supernatural (1990s)

Armie Hammer

as Bucky Barnes in Captain America: the Winter Soldier [2014]

Olivia Rodrigo

as Leah in Prom

Flesh and Blood

as 1985 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

One False Move

as 1992 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

Basic Instinct (Movie)

as 1992 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

Audition

as 1999 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

All About My Mother

as 1999 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

Bringing Out the Dead

as 1999 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

Any Given Sunday

as 1999 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

This is Spinal Tap

as 1984 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

Amadeus (film)

as 1984 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

Stop Making Sense

as 1984 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years

School of Rock

as 2003 in Pop Culture Throughout the Years