Suggestions by @ruddy_hell_its_danny

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Lainey Kluck in Happiest Town On Earth

Anthony Keyvan

as John King in Happiest Town On Earth

Ayren Sainté

as John Lyttle in Happiest Town On Earth

Jensen Ackles

as Sherman Nottingham in Happiest Town On Earth

Abigail Cowen

as Marian Laing in Happiest Town On Earth

Tom Holland

as Robin Hood in Happiest Town On Earth

Oakes Fegley

as Sidney "Sid" Phillips in Happiest Town On Earth

Retta

as Stella Head in Happiest Town On Earth

Jeffrey Wright

as Don Head in Happiest Town On Earth

Froy Gutierrez

as Kenneth "Ken" Carson in Happiest Town On Earth

Olivia Holt

as Barbara "Barbie" Roberts in Happiest Town On Earth

Ryan Kiera Armstrong

as Molly Davis in Happiest Town On Earth

Asher Angel

as Andy Davis in Happiest Town On Earth

Lili Reinhart

as Bobbi Peters in Happiest Town On Earth

RJ Cyler

as Rex Tyler in Happiest Town On Earth

Freddie Highmore

as Sloan Dogg in Happiest Town On Earth

Noah Guthrie

as Hamilton Bacon in Happiest Town On Earth

Gregg Sulkin

as Buzz Lightyear in Happiest Town On Earth

Graham Phillips

as Woodford "Woody" Pride in Happiest Town On Earth

Emma Kenney

as Jessica "Jessie" Pride in Happiest Town On Earth