Suggestions by @ruddy_hell_its_danny

Willa Holland

as Piper Halliwell in Charmed

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Chris Perry (Halliwell) in Charmed

Levi Miller

as Sebastian Black in Horror High

Jaeden Martell

as Ryder Allen in Horror High

Peyton Elizabeth Lee

as Avery Lang in Horror High

Sofia Wylie

as Taylor Windsor in Horror High

Lizzy Greene

as Lottie Donovan in Horror High

Ruby Rose

as Sarah Mitchell in Horror High

Zoë Kravitz

as Rory Anderson in Horror High

Grant Gustin

as Ben Ferris in Horror High

Evan Peters

as Troy Miller in Horror High

Caleb McLaughlin

as Felix Smith in Horror High

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Ethan Walker in Horror High

John Wesley Shipp

as Professor Harold Montague in Horror High

Kathy Najimy

as Professor Olympia Davenport in Horror High

Matt Smith

as Professor Michael Ogalvie in Horror High

RJ Cyler

as Peter Harrison in Horror High

Ryan Whitney

as Aubrey King in Horror High

Paris Berelc

as Olivia Wu in Horror High

Dylan Sprayberry

as Shayne Elliott in Horror High