Suggestions by @rossrip

Brenton Thwaites

as Peter Parker (Earth-2818) in Spider-verse

Lily Collins

as Mary Jane Watson (Earth-18119) in Spider-verse

Chosen Jacobs

as Hobie Brown (Earth-138) in Spider-verse

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Anya Corazon in Spider-verse

Logan Lerman

as Otto Octavius (Earth-12131) in Spider-verse

Melise

as Cindy Moon in Spider-verse

Sophia Lillis

as Annie Parker (Earth-18119) in Spider-verse

Tom Holland

as Ben Reilly in Spider-verse

Karan Brar

as Pavitr Prabhakar (Earth-50101) in Spider-verse

Henry Cavill

as Billy Braddock (Earth-833) in Spider-verse

Winona Ryder

as Betty Brant (Earth-78227) in Spider-verse

Teagan Croft

as May Parker (Earth-982) in Spider-verse

Thomas Brodie-Sangster

as Peter Parker (Earth-21205) in Spider-verse

Freddie Highmore

as Dr. Aaron Aikman in Spider-verse

John Mulaney

as Peter Porker (Earth-8311) in Spider-verse

Ron Perlman

as Ezekiel Sims (Earth-4) in Spider-verse

Nina Dobrev

as May Reilly (Earth-803) in Spider-verse

Zachary Levi

as Peter Parker (Earth-90214) in Spider-verse

Avan Jogia

as Miguel O'Hara in Spider-verse

Idris Elba

as Jefferson Davis in Spider-verse