Suggestions by @robertwashburn

Paul Blart

as Peppino in Pizza Tower -Chef's Kiss Adaptation-

Score: 0

Kevin James

as Peppino in Pizza Tower -Chef's Kiss Adaptation-

Score: 0

Harvey Atkin

as Gustavo in Pizza Tower: The Movie (2028)

Score: +1

Kevin Hart

as Gustavo in Pizza Tower: The Movie (2028)

Score: -1

Mark Fishbach

as Pepperman in Pizza Tower: The Movie (2028)

Score: 0

Crisp Rat

as The Noise in Pizza Tower: The Movie (2028)

Score: 0

Joel Johansson

as Peppino Spaghetti in Pizza Tower: The Movie (2028)

Score: +1