Suggestions by @robertbarnes

Marwan Kenzari

as Imhotep in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: 0

Alexander Skarsgård

as Count Dracula in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: 0

Michael Fassbender

as Count Dracula in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Lawrence Talbot in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Dave Bautista

as Adam in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2

Steven Yuen

as Henry Jekyll in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2

Matthew Lillard

as Jack Griffin in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2

Eric Bana

as Joel Miller in The Last of Us (2013)

Score: +2

Danny Huston

as Frank Booth in Blue Velvet (2006)

Score: 0

Dylan Baker

as Frank Booth in Blue Velvet (2006)

Score: 0

Bryan Cranston

as Dr. Sean Maguire in Good Will Hunting (2007)

Score: +6

Christian Bale

as Henry Jekyll in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Charlie Day

as Fritz in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2

Toni Collette

as Bride's Assistant in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Andy Serkis

as Renfield in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2

Paul Dano

as Victor Frankenstein in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +3

Terry Notary

as Gill-Man in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2

Bill Hader

as Jack Griffin in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Erik in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2

Daniel Radcliffe

as Quasimodo in Halloween Horror Nights - Universal Monsters

Score: +2