Suggestions by @robeenhere

Jonah Hill

as Mr. D in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

Score: -8

Seth Rogen

as Mr. D in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

Score: -7

Eva Green

as The Lady of the Green Kirtle in The Chronicles of Narnia (Upcoming Netflix Adaptations)

Score: +6

Alexander Molony

as Digory Kirke in The Chronicles of Narnia (Upcoming Netflix Adaptations)

Score: -2

Carmel Laniado

as Susan Pevensie in The Chronicles of Narnia (Upcoming Netflix Adaptations)

Score: -4

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Uncle Andrew in The Chronicles of Narnia (Upcoming Netflix Adaptations)

Score: +1

Ethan Slater

as Boq in Wicked (Upcoming Movie Adaptation)

Score: +8

Sydney Park

as Sue Snell in Carrie

Score: +1

Geraldine James

as Margaret White in Carrie

Score: +1

Milly Shapiro

as Carrie White in Carrie

Score: +3

Daveed Diggs

as Dr. Pomatter in Waitress

Score: +1

George Salazar

as Oggie in Waitress

Score: +1

Hayley Kiyoko

as Dawn in Waitress

Score: +1

Skylar Astin

as Earl in Waitress

Score: +1

Stephanie Hsu

as Dawn in Waitress

Score: +1

Uzo Aduba

as Becky in Waitress

Score: +1

Robin de Jesús

as Dr. Pomatter in Waitress

Score: 0

Emmy Raver-Lampman

as Jenna in Waitress

Score: +2

Eiza González

as Elphaba in Wicked (Upcoming Movie Adaptation)

Score: 0

Michaela Jaé Rodriguez

as Elphaba in Wicked (Upcoming Movie Adaptation)

Score: -1