Suggestions by @ringothedrummer

Winston Duke

as Jim Gordon in Gotham (Season Two)

Tim Blake Nelson

as The Killer in Gotham (Season Two)

Spoiler

as The Killer in Gotham (Season Two)

Bobby Cannavale

as Rupert Thorne in Gotham (Season One)

Jessica Chastain

as “MURDERED!” in Gotham (Season One)

Matthew Rhys

as “MURDERED!” in Gotham (Season One)

Spoiler

as “MURDERED!” in Gotham (Season One)

Julia Antonelli

as Sofia Falcone in Gotham (Season One)

Vera Farmiga

as Louisa Falcone in Gotham (Season One)

Walker Scobell

as Harvey Dent in Gotham (Season One)

Eric Dane

as Christopher Dent in Gotham (Season One)

Zion Broadnax

as Selina Kyle in Gotham (Season One)

Jack Austin

as Bruce Wayne in Gotham (Season One)

Julian Hilliard

as Edward Nygma in Gotham (Season One)

Ben Mendelsohn

as Edgar Nygma in Gotham (Season One)

Nathalie Emmanuel

as Barbara Kean in Gotham (Season One)

Harry Melling

as Oswald Cobblepot in Gotham (Season One)

Idris Elba

as Alfred Pennyworth in Gotham (Season One)

Jessica Chastain

as Martha Wayne in Gotham (Season One)

Matthew Rhys

as Thomas Wayne in Gotham (Season One)