Suggestions by @rieyannajarrett
20 suggestions
Matthew Stiller
as Bunny Man in Creepypasta
Joshua Lang
as Bunny Man in Creepypasta
Jeff the Killer
as Jeff The Killer in Creepypasta
Evan Peters
as Jeff The Killer in Creepypasta
Ben Drowned
as Ben Drowned in Creepypasta
Ross Lynch
as Ben Drowned in Creepypasta
Sally Williams
as Sally Williams in Creepypastas Characters.
Jackwise Clown
as Laughing Jack in Creepypastas Characters.
Laughing Jack
as Laughing Jack in Creepypastas Characters.
Melanie Paxson
as Fairy Godmother in Ever After High Live Action
Noah LaLonde
as Daring Charming in Ever After High Live Action
Evan Smith
as Daring Charming in Ever After High Live Action
Julian Hilliard
as Alistair Wonderland in Ever After High
Tanner Buchanan
as Alistair Wonderland in Ever After High
Roman Griffin Davis
as Alistair Wonderland in Ever After High
Tanner Buchanan
as Alistair Wonderland in Ever After High
Ty Simpkins
as Alistair Wonderland in Ever After High
Javier Botet
as Slender-Man in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Jenna Ortega
as Jane The Killer in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Cody Fern
as Candy Pop in Creepypastas Characters.