Suggestions by @reidburger

Alan Ritchson

as Carl in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Jack Quaid

as Jim in The Mayor of Noobtown

Patrick Stewart

as Porthus in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Diego Luna

as Anton in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Michael Peña

as Paz in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Martha Higareda

as Sister Ines in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Peter Dinklage

as Quasar in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Christina Hendricks

as Madison in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Gemma Chan

as Li Na in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Maggie Q

as Lexis in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Millie Bobby Brown

as Rosetta in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Julianne Moore

as Astrid in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Elizabeth Banks

as Cascadia in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Channing Tatum

as Brad in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Katey Sagal

as Carl's Mom in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Patrick Warburton

as Carl's Father in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Jessica Matten

as Gwen in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Erin Moriarty

as Britney in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Gina Torres

as Queen Imogen in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Monica Bellucci

as Meriam Dom in Dungeon Crawler Carl