Suggestions by @randomcaster
565 suggestions
Maurice Beverly
as Nick Kroll in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Poe Dameron
as Oscar Isaac in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Spider-Man 2099 (Miguel O'Hara)
as Oscar Isaac in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Moon Knight (Marvel Cinematic Universe)
as Oscar Isaac in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Blitzo (Helluva Boss)
as Brandon Rogers in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Indiana Jones (Dr. Henry Walton Jones Jr.)
as Harrison Ford in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Han Solo
as Harrison Ford in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Sebastian The Crab (The Little Mermaid)
as Daveed Diggs in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
The Rat King
as Daveed Diggs in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Charlie Chaplin
as Robert Downey Jr. in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Sherlock Holmes (Character)
as Robert Downey Jr. in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Thomas Jefferson
as Daveed Diggs in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Santa Claus
as Seth Rogen in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Norm the Genie
as Norm Macdonald in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Pigeon
as Norm Macdonald in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Courtney (Dead End)
as Emily Osment in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Ronald "Mac" McDonald
as Rob McElhenney in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Fred Jones (Velma)
as Glenn Howerton in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Dennis Reynolds
as Glenn Howerton in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)
as Ryan Reynolds in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)