Suggestions by @randomcaster

Kai (Kung Fu Panda 3)

as J.K. Simmons in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Omni-Man (Nolan Grayson)

as J.K. Simmons in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

J. Jonah Jameson

as J.K. Simmons in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Superman (DCEU)

as Henry Cavill in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Ebenezer Scrooge

as Jim Carrey in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Uncle Fester Addams

as Fred Armisen in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Olaf (Frozen)

as Josh Gad in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Chief Bogo

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Knuckles the Echidna (Paramount)

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Bloodsport (DCEU)

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

James P. Sullivan

as John Goodman in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Pacha

as John Goodman in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Ray the Firefly

as Jim Cummings in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Bart Simpson

as Nancy Cartwright in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Eugene Harold Krabs

as Clancy Brown in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Scuttle (Awkwafina)

as Awkwafina in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Mufasa

as James Earl Jones in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Anakin Skywalker (Darth Vader)

as James Earl Jones in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Glenn Quagmire

as Seth MacFarlane in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Ted The Bear

as Seth MacFarlane in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)