Suggestions by @raininhell

Jensen Ackles

as Leon in Souls trilogy

Score: +1

Tarayummy

as Lenora Astalis in All saints high series

Score: +1

Ethan Dolan

as Evan in Good Girl Complex

Score: +1

mgk

as Mikolaj Wilk in Sophie Lark Universe

Score: +1

Ethan Dolan

as Evan Hartley in Bad Girl Reputation

Score: +1

Grayson Dolan

as Cooper in Good Girl Complex

Score: +1

Brynne Rosetta

as Taylor Marsh in Off Campus, Briar U, and Campus Diaries series

Score: +2

Vinnie Hacker

as Collin Fitzgerald in Off Campus, Briar U, and Campus Diaries series

Score: +1

Melissa Fumero

as Gio in Jar of Hearts

Score: 0

Jensen Ackles

as Calvin in Jar of Hearts

Score: +3

James Lafferty

as Creighton King in Rina Kent Verse Fan Cast

Score: 0

Freddie Fox

as Raihn in The Serpent and the Wings of Night

Score: -3

Jared Padalecki

as Ford Grant in Wild Love

Score: -4

Ewan Mitchell

as Hael in The Havoc Boys

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Victor in The Havoc Boys

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as Aaron in The Havoc Boys

Score: +1

Mason Dye

as Tyler Corbin in Zodiac Academy

Score: 0

Charles Gillespie

as Seth in Zodiac Academy

Score: +2

Charles Gillespie

as Seth Capella in Zodiac Academy

Score: +1

Olivia Holt

as Clay Collins in Tryst Six Venom

Score: -1