Suggestions by @qwerty

Xolo Maridueña

as Blue Beetle in The Avengers League

Score: +1

Patrick Page

as Claude frollo in My Disney villains

Score: +2

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Female in Actor/Actress Crushes

Score: +6

Wayne Brady

as Django in Ratatouille:The Broadway Musical

Score: +2

Keanu Reeves

as Kraven the hunter in Spiderman 3

Score: +1

Andrew Barth Feldman

as Charlito tolentino in The 25th annual Putnam county spelling bee

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Johnny Blaze in Marvel Universe

Score: +4

James Monroe Iglehart

as Audrey 2 in Little Shop of Horrors

Score: +2

Ben Platt

as Bobby Strong in Urinetown

Score: +2

Peter Dinklage

as Lord Farquad in Shrek Eternal

Score: 0

Verne Troyer

as Shrek Wazowski in Shrek Eternal

Score: +2

Ben Cook

as Choreographer in Urinetown

Score: +2

Alan Menken

as Director in Urinetown

Score: +1

Christian Borle

as Robbie the Stockfish / Business Man #1 in Urinetown

Score: +2

Christian Bale

as Robbie the Stockfish / Business Man #1 in Urinetown

Score: 0

Daniel Breaker

as Tiny Tom / Dr. Billeaux in Urinetown

Score: +1

Celia Keenan-Bolger

as Soupy Sue / Cladwell's Secretary in Urinetown

Score: +2

Stephanie J. Block

as Little Becky Two Shoes / Mrs. Millennium in Urinetown

Score: +1

Arielle Jacobs

as Old Woman / Josephine Strong in Urinetown

Score: +2

Nathan Lane

as Old Man Strong / Hot Blades Harry in Urinetown

Score: 0