Suggestions by @quantumparagon

Jessica Chastain

as Harley Quinn in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -18

Jim Carrey

as The Joker in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -21

Christoph Waltz

as Mad Hatter in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -4

Bobby Cannavale

as Black Mask in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +14

Jason Statham

as Black Mask in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +68

Joaquin Phoenix

as The Joker in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +36

Willem Dafoe

as The Joker in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +168

David Harbour

as Detective Harvey Bullock in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +16

Donal Logue

as Detective Harvey Bullock in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +7

John Goodman

as Detective Harvey Bullock in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +26

Liam Neeson

as Commissioner James Gordon in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -8

Bryan Cranston

as Commissioner James Gordon in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +64

J.K. Simmons

as Commissioner James Gordon in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +21

Eiza González

as Catwoman in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +36

Daisy Ridley

as Catwoman in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -4

Emmy Rossum

as Catwoman in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -13

Morena Baccarin

as Catwoman in “The Batman” fancast

Score: +27

Bill Nighy

as Alfred Pennyworth in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -4

John Cleese

as Alfred Pennyworth in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -9

Geoffrey Rush

as Alfred Pennyworth in “The Batman” fancast

Score: -8