Suggestions by @pointman528491

Joaquin Phoenix

as Lex Luthor in Superman

Olivia Cooke

as Samantha Evelyn Cook in Ready Player One

Ruben Fleischer

as Director in Venom

Tom Hardy

as Venom in Venom

Mike Mignola

as Writer in Hellboy

Ian McShane

as Trevor Bruttenholm in Hellboy

Callie Hernandez

as Liz Sherman in Hellboy

Neil Marshall

as Director in Hellboy

Wil Wheaton

as Gordie Lachance in The Body

David Harbour

as Hellboy in Hellboy

Matt Reeves

as Director in Jaws

Andy Serkis

as Quint in Jaws

Will Poulter

as Gomer Pyle in Full Metal Jacket

Doug Liman

as Director in Under The Radar

Imogen Poots

as Eve L. Abbott in Under The Radar

Dylan O'Brien

as John R. Madsen in Under The Radar

Madelaine Petsch

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man

Lili Reinhart

as Gwen Stacy in Spider-Man

Sam Rockwell

as Deadpool in Deadpool (2009 Release)

Britt Robertson

as Supergirl in Superman