Suggestions by @phantomking

Steve Martin

as Buddy Ryan in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Jon Bernthal

as Ron Rivera in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Mike Colter

as Mike Singletary in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Faizon Love

as William Perry in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Mark Henry

as William Perry in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: -1

Michael B. Jordan

as Walter Payton in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Ashton Kutcher

as Jim McMahon in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Michael B. Jordan

as Jim McMahon in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Joe Pesci

as Buddy Ryan in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: -1

Robert De Niro

as Coach Mike Ditka in Chicago Bears: Road to greatness 1985

Score: +1

Michael B. Jordan

as Chris Ostreicher in American Pie

Score: -1

Alan Ritchson

as Steve Stifler in American Pie

Score: +3

Jennifer Aniston

as Stiflers Mom in American Pie

Score: +1

Jesse Eisenberg

as Jim Levenstien in American Pie

Score: +2

Jesse Eisenberg

as Coach Marshall in American Pie

Score: -4

Jason Biggs

as Noah Levenstien in American Pie

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Paul Finch in American Pie

Score: +3

Alan Ritchson

as Chris Ostreicher in American Pie

Score: 0

Zac Efron

as Steve Stifler in American Pie

Score: +2