Suggestions by @peanutbutter

Paul Scheer

as Vizzini in The Princess Bride

Sebastian Stan

as Prince Humperdinck in The Princess Bride

Ted Danson

as Grandfather in The Princess Bride

Stephan James

as Westley in The Princess Bride

Stephen James

as Westley in The Princess Bride

Natalia Dyer

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride

Keegan-Michael Key

as Hermes in Hercules

Bonnie Hunt

as Hera in Hercules

Renée Elise Goldsberry

as Melpomene in Hercules

Beck Bennett

as Pain in Hercules

Bill Pullman

as Zeus in Hercules

Rachel Bloom

as Megara in Hercules

Lea Thompson

as Martha Kent in Superman

James Cromwell

as General Zod in Superman

Kyle Mooney

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman

Woody Harrelson

as Jonathan Kent in Superman

Christoph Waltz

as Jor-El in Superman

Rob Reiner

as Perry White in Superman

Karen Gillan

as Lois Lane in Superman

Paul Giamatti

as The Penguin in The Perfect Batman Film Cast