Suggestions by @pauldmckay
41 suggestions
Graham Norton
as Saruman in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Neil Patrick Harris
as Elrond in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Dick Van Dyke
as Gandalf in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jenna Ortega
as Arwen in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Pete Davidson
as Gollum in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jeremy Clarkson
as Bilbo in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Kurt Russell
as Eomer in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
The Great Khali
as Legolas in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Chris Pontius
as Merry in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Steve-O
as Pippin in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Matt Damon
as Theoden in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Joe Rogan
as Gimli in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Joe Rogan
as Theoden in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Russell Brand
as Denethor in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Paul Rudd
as Sam in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Harrison Ford
as Witch-King of Angmar in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
John Cena
as Aragorn in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jennifer Coolidge
as Galadriel in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Goldie Hawn
as Eowyn in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Aziz Ansari
as Frodo in Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast