Suggestions by @oscarramirezquiroz

Sigourney Weaver

as Crooked Rook in Pale

Elisha Cuthbert

as Edith James in Pale

Jason Schwartzman

as Lawrence T. Bristow in Pale

Alexander Skarsgård

as Ted Havens in Pale

Thomas Barbusca

as Seth Bellanger in Pale

Joel McHale

as Alexander Belanger in Pale

Henry Golding

as Tanner Gilpin in Pale

Brian Posehn

as Brett Hayward in Pale

Isis Hainsworth

as Brie Callie in Pale

Vinnie Jones

as Contender in Ward

Nichole Bloom

as March in Ward

Benjamin Wadsworth

as Byron Vera in Ward

Caleb Landry Jones

as Wye Bellanger in Pale

Clint Howard

as Charles Abrams in Pale

Jackie Earle Haley

as Charles Abrams in Pale

Tara Strong

as Maricica in Pale

Jared Keeso

as John Stiles in Pale

Gus Johnson

as Chase Whitt in Pale

Robert Sheehan

as Daniel Alitzer in Pale

Ryan Reynolds

as Alexander Belanger in Pale