Suggestions by @oooooooo

Tom Hiddleston

as Manchester Black in Superman: Legacy

Score: +1

Eddie Murphy

as Dr. Facilier in The Princess and the Frog (Live Action)

Score: -2

Pete Holmes

as Albus Dumbledore in A Very Potter Musical

Score: +1

Michael Cera

as Bug in Starship

Score: +1

Keke Palmer

as Lois Lane in DCEU Rebooted

Score: -3

Matthew McConaughey

as Bill Clinton in Trump

Score: +1

Cristin Milioti

as Annie Edison in Community (2019-2025)

Score: -1

Harvey Guillén

as Bing Bong in Inside Out (Live Action Remake)

Score: +4

Kate Micucci

as Sadness in Inside Out (Live Action Remake)

Score: +8

Larry David

as Cranky Kong in The Super Mario Bros Movie

Score: +2

Alexander Skarsgård

as Arthur Curry in Titans (DC Comics)

Score: -1

Darren Criss

as Clark Kent in Titans (DC Comics)

Score: 0

Emma Myers

as Stephanie Brown in Titans (DC Comics)

Score: +1

Alan Tudyk

as The Pyro in Team Fortress 2

Score: +3

Sacha Baron Cohen

as The Spy in Team Fortress 2

Score: +2

Idris Elba

as The Demoman in Team Fortress 2

Score: +6

James Gunn

as Director in Team Fortress 2

Score: +4

Pete Davidson

as The Scout in Team Fortress 2

Score: -2

Christian Bale

as Jack Torrance in The Shining

Score: +7