Suggestions by @oldchatot
1,319 suggestions
Patrick Stewart
as Gandalf in The Silmarillion
Ian McKellen
as Gandalf in The Silmarillion
Charles Dance
as Saruman in The Silmarillion
Joe Manganiello
as Bëor in The Silmarillion
Alexander Ludwig
as Hador in The Silmarillion
Justin Hartley
as Huor in The Silmarillion
Stuart Townsend
as Annael in The Silmarillion
Tom Welling
as Huor in The Silmarillion
Matthew Goode
as Finrod Felagund in The Silmarillion
Rupert Penry-Jones
as Finwë in The Silmarillion
Amadeus Serafini
as Beren Erchamion in The Silmarillion
Robert Kazinsky
as Mahtan in The Silmarillion
Peter Claffey
as Tuor in The Silmarillion
Tom Hughes
as Angrod in The Silmarillion
Peter Claffey
as Tuor in The Silmarillion
David Dastmalchian
as Eöl in The Silmarillion
Domhnall Gleeson
as Finarfin in The Silmarillion
Eddie Redmayne
as Daeron in The Silmarillion
Finn Cole
as Anárion in The Silmarillion
Hero Fiennes Tiffin
as Isildur in The Silmarillion