Suggestions by @oldchatot
1,301 suggestions
Peter Dinklage
as Mîm in The Silmarillion
Jared Harris
as Gandalf in The Silmarillion
Geoffrey Rush
as Gandalf in The Silmarillion
Eric Bana
as Círdan in The Silmarillion
Jacob Elordi
as Maeglin in The Silmarillion
Patrick Stewart
as Gandalf in The Silmarillion
Ian McKellen
as Gandalf in The Silmarillion
Charles Dance
as Saruman in The Silmarillion
Charlie Hunnam
as Ingwë in The Silmarillion
James McAvoy
as Tilion in The Silmarillion
Wilf Scolding
as Orodreth in The Silmarillion
Joe Manganiello
as Bëor in The Silmarillion
Alexander Ludwig
as Hador in The Silmarillion
Justin Hartley
as Huor in The Silmarillion
Jason Momoa
as Oromë in The Silmarillion
Stuart Townsend
as Annael in The Silmarillion
Tom Welling
as Huor in The Silmarillion
Mia Goth
as Nellas in The Silmarillion
Jared Padalecki
as Maedhros in The Silmarillion
Matthew Goode
as Finrod Felagund in The Silmarillion