Suggestions by @ojmcclanahan

Saoirse Ronan

as Delirium in Shadow of The Bat

Jackie Earle Haley

as Destiny in Shadow of The Bat

Zach Villa

as Dream in Shadow of The Bat

Elizabeth Gillies

as Death in Shadow of The Bat

Madison Iseman

as Amy Winston in Shadow of The Bat

Neil Patrick Harris

as Michael Carter in Shadow of The Bat

Justin Hartley

as Samael in Shadow of The Bat

Ema Horvath

as Nancy Thompson in A Nightmare On Elm Street

Nathan Fillion

as Rex Mason in Shadow of The Bat

Samara Weaving

as Gabrielle Doe in Shadow of The Bat

Hero Fiennes Tiffin

as Prince Brion Markov in Shadow of The Bat

Shelley Hennig

as Jessica Cruz in Shadow of The Bat

KJ Apa

as Wally West in Shadow of The Bat

Leem Lubany

as Meena Dhawan in Shadow of The Bat

Kevin Grevioux

as King Grodd in Shadow of The Bat

Kate Mara

as Iris West in Shadow of The Bat

Danika Yarosh

as Karen Starr in Shadow of The Bat

Arden Cho

as Jade Nguyen in Shadow of The Bat

Linden Porco

as Bat-Mite in Shadow of The Bat

Lupita Nyong'o

as Mari McCabe in Shadow of The Bat