Suggestions by @oceaneyes

Sam Claflin

as Apollo in The Odyssey

Score: +1

Travis Fimmel

as Ares in The Odyssey

Score: +1

Indiana Evans

as Calypso in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Cara Delevingne

as Scylla in The Odyssey

Score: +2

David Tennant

as Hermes in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Simone Ashley

as Circe in The Odyssey

Score: 0

Ana de Armas

as Aphrodite in The Odyssey

Score: +1

Lena Headey

as Hera in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Josh Brolin

as Zeus in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Ryan Hurst

as Poseidon in The Odyssey

Score: +1

Alicia Vikander

as Athena in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Sebastian Croft

as Telemachus in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Eva Green

as Penelope in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Oscar Isaac

as Odysseus in The Odyssey

Score: +2

Bel Powley

as Olivia Wheaton in Belladonna Series

Score: +1

Kristin Scott Thomas

as Magda in Belladonna Series

Score: +2

Maisie Williams

as Diana Blackwater in Belladonna Series

Score: +1

Lupita Nyong'o

as Solanine in Belladonna Series

Score: 0

Matthew Goode

as Edward Farrow in Belladonna Series

Score: +1

Rebecca Hall

as Rima Farrow in Belladonna Series

Score: +1