Suggestions by @ntnoah

Robert Pattinson

as Fred in A Christmas Carol

Score: -1

Ian McKellen

as Jacob Marley in A Christmas Carol

Score: +1

Ralph Ineson

as Jacob Marley in A Christmas Carol

Score: +1

Jodi Comer

as Ghost of Christmas Past in A Christmas Carol

Score: -1

Bill Nighy

as Jacob Marley in A Christmas Carol

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as Bob Crachit in A Christmas Carol

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Ebeneezer Scrooge in A Christmas Carol

Score: +2

Robert Eggers

as Writer in A Christmas Carol

Score: +1

Robert Eggers

as Director in A Christmas Carol

Score: +1

Ray Fisher

as Kang the Conqueror in The Fantastic Four

Score: -1

Ray Fisher

as Kang the Conqueror in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

Ben Ahlers

as W.L.F Soilder in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

Alanna Ubach

as Hanrahan in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

Baylen D. Bielitz

as Benjamin Miller in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

Danny Ramirez

as Manny in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

Steven Yeun

as Jordan in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

David Miranda

as Young Tommy in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

Andrew Díaz

as Young Joel in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

Joe Pantoliano

as Eugene in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1

Robert John Burke

as Seth in HBO's The Last of Us: Season 1 (Recast)

Score: +1