Suggestions by @normal_knees

Joaquin Phoenix

as Sherlock Holmes in Disney's Sherlock Holmes (1995)

Score: +1

Ed Harris

as Dr John Watson in Disney's Sherlock Holmes (1995)

Score: +1

Bruce Willis

as Sherlock Holmes in Disney's Sherlock Holmes (1995)

Score: 0

Willem Dafoe

as Sherlock Holmes in Disney's Sherlock Holmes (1995)

Score: +2

Dustin Hoffman

as Dr John Watson in Disney's Sherlock Holmes (1995)

Score: -1

Bob Hoskins

as Dr John Watson in Disney's Sherlock Holmes (1995)

Score: 0

Christopher Lloyd

as Sherlock Holmes in Disney's Sherlock Holmes (1995)

Score: +1

Brian Blessed

as Inspector Lestrade in Sherlock Holmes (1990)

Score: +1

Bob Hoskins

as Dr Watson in Sherlock Holmes (1990)

Score: +1

George C. Scott

as Professor Moriarty in Sherlock Holmes (1990)

Score: +1

Jonathan Pryce

as Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock Holmes (1990)

Score: 0

Jonathan Pryce

as Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows (1993)

Score: +1

Miles Fisher

as Qrow Branwen in Live action rwby

Score: +1

David Anders

as Father John Patrick Francis Mulcahy in M*A*S*H

Score: +2

Jamie Kennedy

as Scarecrow in Justice league

Score: +2

Will Branner

as Biff Tannen(Young) in Back to The Future the Musical

Score: +2

Stephen Merchant

as Sherlock Holmes in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: -2

Josh Gad

as Sweet Tooth in Justice league

Score: +2

Jim Carrey

as Sweet Tooth in Justice league

Score: 0

Paul Giamatti

as Sweet Tooth in Justice league

Score: +2