Suggestions by @nitrogencake

James Caan

as Sean Penn in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +2

Chris Cooper

as Ethan Hawke in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +1

Albert Finney

as Stellan Skarsgård in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +2

Michelle Williams

as Elle Fanning in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +3

Edward James Olmos

as Benicio del Toro in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +2

Luis Guzmán

as Wagner Moura in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +1

Will Smith

as Michael B. Jordan in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +2

Jane Lynch

as Mom in Futurama

Score: +6

Bill Irwin

as Professor Hubert J. Farnsworth in Futurama

Score: +7

Jesse Eisenberg

as The Actor in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Jeffrey Wright

as CIA Superior in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Patrick Fabian

as Palmer DeBakey Smith in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Tracy Letts

as Ted in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Olivia Colman

as Katie Cox in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Channing Tatum

as Chad Feldheimer in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Edward Norton

as Osborne Cox in Burn After Reading

Score: +5

Kaitlin Olson

as Linda Litzke in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Bradley Cooper

as Harry Pfarrer in Burn After Reading

Score: +4

Charles Durning

as John Goodman’s Character in DIGGER (1986)

Score: +3

Winston Duke

as Atrocitus in Green Lantern Corps.

Score: +2