Suggestions by @nitrogencake

Robert Duvall

as 2026 in Deceased Celebrities Face Claims Sorted by Year of Death

Score: +8

Kristen Stewart

as Michelle Fuller in Recast the Oscars: 2025 Edition

Score: +2

Benny Safdie

as The Hulk in The Avengers

Score: +9

Joe Alwyn

as Captain Marvel in The Avengers

Score: +6

Mackenzie Davis

as Black Widow in The Avengers

Score: +3

Darren Criss

as Wonder Man in The Avengers

Score: +4

Aaron Pierre

as The Falcon in The Avengers

Score: +8

Boyd Holbrook

as Hawkeye in The Avengers

Score: +10

Jeremy Strong

as The Leader in The Avengers

Score: +6

Andy Griffith

as Dr. Rudy Blatnoyd, D.D.S. in Inherent Vice (1993)

Score: +1

David Krumholtz

as Bernie Bernbaum in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +2

Stavros Halkias

as Brandt in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +1

Billy Bob Thornton

as Jeffrey "The Big" Lebowski in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +2

Clancy Brown

as Jeffrey "The Big" Lebowski in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +2

J.K. Simmons

as Jeffrey "The Big" Lebowski in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +2

Ray Winstone

as Jeffrey "The Big" Lebowski in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +2

Nicolas Cage

as Jeffrey "The Big" Lebowski in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +2

Bradley Cooper

as Jerry Lundegaard in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Sidney J. Mussburger in Almost Cast: The Coen Brothers

Score: +1