Suggestions by @nickfindlay

Kathryn Hahn

as Jerri Manthey in Survivor

Score: +1

Donald Glover

as Wendell Holland in Survivor

Score: +1

Kat Dennings

as Aubry Bracco in Survivor

Score: +1

J.J. Abrams

as Director in Captain America: the Winter Soldier (2004)

Score: +2

Jared Padalecki

as Oscar "Ozzy" Lusth in Survivor

Score: +1

Krysten Ritter

as Jenna Morasca in Survivor

Score: +1

Wendie Malick

as Tina Wesson in Survivor

Score: +1

Simu Liu

as Yul Kwon in Survivor

Score: +1

Nick Offerman

as Rupert Boneham in Survivor

Score: +1

Ming-Na Wen

as Shii Ann Huang in Survivor

Score: +1

Natalia Dyer

as Kelly Wiggelsworth in Survivor

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Rudy Boesch in Survivor

Score: +1

Sara Sampaio

as Abi-Maria Gomes in Survivor

Score: +1

Angela Kinsey

as Kass McQuillen in Survivor

Score: +1

Lana Parrilla

as Sandra Diaz Twine in Survivor

Score: +1

Thomas Ian Griffith

as Benjamin "Coach" Wade in Survivor

Score: +1

Steven Seagal

as Benjamin "Coach" Wade in Survivor

Score: -1

Chris Pratt

as James 'JT" Thomas in Survivor

Score: +1

Bradley Cooper

as Russell Hantz in Survivor

Score: +1

Channing Tatum

as Colby Donaldson in Survivor

Score: +1