Suggestions by @neilcicirega

Joaquin Phoenix

as SK-73 in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Shannon Purser

as Annie Wintersummer in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Patti LuPone

as Gem Lovejoy in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Toni Collette

as Gem Lovejoy in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Alex Wolff

as Elanthielrian Wright in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Keke Palmer

as Marigold Westberry in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Keke Palmer

as Anna Marie in MCU’s X-Men

Score: -1

Glenn Howerton

as Sougle Wackamole in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Nicolas Cage

as Sir Mister Person in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Bella Ramsey

as Jacob Aaron in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Storm Reid

as Quinn in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Brendan Fraser

as Art g'Rish in Unprepared Caster

Score: +1

Steven Yeun

as Glenn Close in Dungeons and Daddies

Score: +4

Jim Carrey

as Scam likely in Dungeons and Daddies

Score: +4

Chris Hemsworth

as Hardwon Surefoot in Not Another D&D Podcast: Bahumia

Score: +1