Suggestions by @ms_mosel
397 suggestions
Giovanni Ribisi
as Ezra in Marty Supreme (Recasted)
Larry Saperstein
as Morty Rifkin in Blue Moon (Stage Adaptation)
Isis Hainsworth
as Rachel Mizler in Marty Supreme (Recasted)
Byron Jennings
as E.B. White in Blue Moon (Stage Adaptation)
Bobby Cannavale
as Eddie in Blue Moon (Stage Adaptation)
Elle Fanning
as Elizabeth Weiland in Blue Moon (Stage Adaptation)
Matt Doyle
as Richard Rodgers in Blue Moon (Stage Adaptation)
Ethan Hawke
as Lorenz Hart in Blue Moon (Stage Adaptation)
Chris Colfer
as Peter Allen in The Boy From Oz
Eden Espinosa
as Mother Gothel in Tangled (Live Action)
Madison Bailey
as The White Lotus in Actors/Actresses who should join certain franchises
Brie Larson
as Blanche in A Streetcar Named Desire (2022)
Lily Allen
as Persephone in Hadestown (2025)
Dempsey Bryk
as Adam Fisher in The Summer I Turned Pretty prequel
Emma Myers
as Meg Kincaid in Merrily We Roll Along
Sofia Wylie
as Corie Bratter in Barefoot in the Park
Paul Mescal
as Paul Bratter in Barefoot in the Park
Olivia Rose Keegan
as Tina Powers in That Thing You Do! (Stage Musical Adaptation)
Francesca Capaldi
as Beverly Donofrio in Riding In Cars With Boys (Remake)
Joshua Bassett
as Melchior Gabor in Spring Awakening