Suggestions by @mrq

Ben Affleck

as Thomas Wayne in Batman (2009)

Rachel McAdams

as Harleen Quinzel in Batman (2009)

Cillian Murphy

as Jonathan Crane in Batman (2009)

BD Wong

as Hugo Strange in Batman (2009)

Matt Smith

as "The Red Hood" in Batman (2009)

Richard Kind

as Oswald Cobblepot in Batman (2009)

Mark Ruffalo

as Jim Gordon in Batman (2009)

Brandon Routh

as Clark Kent in Batman (2009)

Richard E. Grant

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman (2009)

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Bruce Wayne in Batman (2009)

Conan Stevens

as Micah Flint in Superman (2008)

Cary Elwes

as Carl Draper in Superman (2008)

Vera Farmiga

as Lara Lor-Van in Superman (2008)

Jude Law

as Jor-El in Superman (2008)

Margo Martindale

as Martha Kent in Superman (2008)

Bill Pullman

as Jonathan Kent in Superman (2008)

Laurence Fishburne

as Perry White in Superman (2008)

Jensen Ackles

as John Corben in Superman (2008)

Shaw Madson

as Phillip Karnowsky in Superman (2008)

Yvonne Strahovski

as Mercy Graves in Superman (2008)