Suggestions by @moti999

William Defoe

as Dante in Dante's Inferno

Score: +1

Lars von Trier

as Director in Dante's Inferno

Score: +1

Chris Hemsworth

as Robin Hood in Robin Hood

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as Robin Hood in Robin Hood

Score: +1

Jared Leto

as Robin Hood in Robin Hood

Score: -2

Tim Burton

as Writer in Corpse Bride

Score: +2