Suggestions by @morganedstrom

Zoe Saldaña

as Briar Rose in Fable

Score: -1

Natalie Dormer

as Lady Grey in Fable

Score: +2

Richard Madden

as The Hero of Oakvale in Fable

Score: -1

Dove Cameron

as Evangeline in Red Queen Series

Score: -5

Ivana Baquero

as Mare in Red Queen Series

Score: -23

Ewan McGregor

as Dandelion in The Witcher

Score: +3

Yvonne Strahovski

as Cirilla Fiona Elen Riannon in The Witcher

Score: -14

Natalie Dormer

as Keira Metz in The Witcher

Score: +24

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Alice Liddell in American McGee's Alice

Score: +34