Suggestions by @misterwolf

Mark Wahlberg

as Jacob Stone in The Weight Of The Cross

Score: +2

Stephen Baldwin

as Weston Stone in The Weight Of The Cross

Score: +2

Carrie Underwood

as Rebecca Mayhew in The Weight Of The Cross

Score: +1

Terry Crews

as Michael Hosea in The Weight Of The Cross

Score: +2

Lucas Black

as Carson Denver in The Weight Of The Cross

Score: +1

Anne Hathaway

as Rose Stone in The Weight Of The Cross

Score: +2

Matthew Lillard

as William Afton / Springtrap in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Pedro Pascal

as Henry Emily in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Wes Bentley

as Fritz Smith in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Mary-Louise Parker

as Shelley Myriam Afton in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Ella Anderson

as Vanessa Shelley Afton in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Asher Angel

as Michael Afton in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Julian Dennison

as Seamus Larson in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Finn Wolfhard

as Gregory in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Xochitl Gomez

as Cassie in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Isabelle Fuhrman

as Charlotte Emily / The Marionette in The Mansion of Silent Strings

Score: +2

Monster (Jacob Banks)

as End Credits Song in The Crimson Huntress

Score: +1

John Debney

as Soundtrack Composer in The First Cross

Score: +2

Hans Zimmer and Brian Tyler

as Composer in The First Cross

Score: +2

Zack Snyder

as Cinematographer in The First Cross

Score: +1