Suggestions by @mishafitt

Charlotte Best

as Max Caulfield in Life Is Strange

Cayden Boyd

as Cooper in One Of Us Is Lying

AnnaSophia Robb

as Addy in One Of Us Is Lying

Austin Butler

as Simon in One Of Us Is Lying

Ana Golja

as Bronwyn in One Of Us Is Lying

Cole Sprouse

as Nate in One Of Us Is Lying

Eric Osborne

as Joe in Final Girls

Hana Mae Lee

as Betz in Final Girls

Naya Rivera

as Janelle in Final Girls

Catherine Dyer

as Nancy in Final Girls

Busy Philipps

as Sam in Final Girls

Tiffani-Amber Thiessen

as Lisa in Final Girls

Cam Gigandet

as Coop in Final Girls

Milo Ventimiglia

as Jeff in Final Girls

Amber Stevens West

as Quincy in Final Girls

Nina Dobrev

as Catherine in The Amateurs

Samara Weaving

as Helena in The Amateurs

Josh Duhamel

as Mark Jefferson in Life Is Strange

Lucas Till

as Nathan Prescott in Life Is Strange

Freya Tingley

as Max Caulfield in Life Is Strange