Suggestions by @mikehenry
155 suggestions
Steve Talley
as Dwight Stifler in American Pie Presents: The Beta House! (2025)
Steve Talley
as Dwight Stifler in American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile! (2024)
Tad Hilgenbrink
as Matt Stifler in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Joe Keery
as Daryl Cranston in American Pie Presents: The Beta House! (2025)
Joe Keery
as Daryl Cranston in American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile! (2024)
Mackenzie Ziegler
as Casey Young in American Pie Presents: The Beta House! (2025)
Noah Schnapp
as Chester Stifler in American Pie Presents: The Beta House! (2025)
Chase Hudson
as Leon Smith in American Pie Presents: The Beta House! (2025)
Noah Beck
as Benji Cranston in American Pie Presents: The Beta House! (2025)
Noah Schnapp
as Chester Stifler in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Millie Bobby Brown
as Maggie Lewis in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Joe Trohman
as ( Himself Cameo ) in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Joe Trohman
as Himself Cameo in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Joe Trohman
as Joe Trohman in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Patrick Stump
as ( Himself/Cameo ) in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Addison Rae
as Melissa Bennett in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Noah Beck
as Benji Cranston in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Charli D'Amelio
as Jennifer Oliver in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Unknown God
as Joey Scott in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)
Dixie D'Amelio
as Caroline Alexander in American Pie Presents: The Camp Rock! (2023)