Suggestions by @michelledonalson

Tyler Wladis

as Randy Parker in A Christmas Story LIVE

Score: +1

Andy Walken

as Ralphie Parker in A Christmas Story LIVE

Score: +1

Shahadi Wright Joseph

as Lil' Inez in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Amber Von Tussle in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Derek Hough

as Corny Collins in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Garrett Clayton

as Link Larkin in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +2

Kristin Chenoweth

as Velma Von Tussle in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Ephraim Sykes

as Seaweed J Stubbs in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Jennifer Hudson

as Motormouth Maybelle in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Andrea Martin

as Prudy Pingleton in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Martin Short

as Wilbur Turnblad in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Maddie Baillio

as Tracy Turnblad in Hairspray LIVE

Score: +1

Prince Royce

as Saint Peter in The Passion: New Orleans

Score: +1

Trisha Yearwood

as Mary in The Passion: New Orleans

Score: +1

Chris Daughtry

as Judas Iscariot in The Passion: New Orleans

Score: +1

Seal

as Pontius Pilate in The Passion: New Orleans

Score: +1

Shane Harper

as Disciple #2 in The Passion: New Orleans

Score: +1

Michael W. Smith

as Disciple #1 in The Passion: New Orleans

Score: +2

Jencarlos Canela

as Jesus Christ in The Passion: New Orleans

Score: +2

Andrew Call

as Sonny in Grease LIVE

Score: +2