Suggestions by @michaelcasey
48 suggestions
Dave Bautista
as Bibbo Bibbowski in Superman Legacy (2025)
Score: +2
Tim Daly
as Superman (Kingdom Come) in Superman Legacy (2025)
Score: +2
Warwick Davis
as Ganthet in Green Lantern corps
Score: +3
Kevin Conroy
as Batman in One true Batman
Score: +4
Jon Hamm
as Clark Kent in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Keanu Reeves
as Plastic man in Peacemaker season 2 new characters fancast
Score: +1
Bryan Cranston
as Lex Luthor in Peacemaker season 2 new characters fancast
Score: +1
Michael Rosenbaum
as Lex Luthor in Peacemaker season 2 new characters fancast
Score: 0
Gary Oldman
as Commissioner Gordon in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Vin Diesel
as Mutant leader in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Tom Welling
as Clark Kent in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Commissioner Ellen Yindel in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Sarah Shahi
as Commissioner Ellen Yindel in The Dark Knight returns
Score: -1
Billy Dee Williams
as Two-face in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Mark Hamill
as Joker in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Millie Bobby Brown
as Carrie Kelly in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +1
Josh Brolin
as Batman in The Dark Knight returns
Score: +3
Kevin Conroy
as Impactor in Last Stand of the Wreckers
Score: +1
Joe Keery
as Rodimus Prime in Last Stand of the Wreckers
Score: +1
Andre Braugher
as Ultra Magnus in Last Stand of the Wreckers
Score: +1