Suggestions by @michael21

Jack Quaid

as The Boys sequel in Actors who should Star in Franchises

Timothée Chalamet

as Ryan Butcher (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Josh Segarra

as Saint (season 2) in The Boys sequel

Joe Keery

as Aaron Washington (season 2) in The Boys sequel

Eiza González

as Eleanor Blake (season 2) in The Boys sequel

Charlie Heaton

as Ethan Fam (season 2) in The Boys sequel

Kate Winslet

as Marta Sargent (season 2) in The Boys sequel

Maya Hawke

as Fake Star (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Jason Momoa

as Iron Fist (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Mike Faist

as Herald of Woe (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Ebon Moss-Bachrach

as The Blind Prophet (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as The bloody Mary (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Danai Gurira

as The Mother's Milk 2.0 (season 1) in The Boys sequel

Bill Skarsgård

as The Successor (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Skeet Ulrich

as Elijah Cohen (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Jeff Bridges

as Arthur Donovan (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Lupita Nyong'o

as Carla Reyes (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Nastasya Samburskaya

as Nina Volkova (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Jack Black

as Hank Grimes (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel

Allison Williams

as Ivy Chen (season 1, 2) in The Boys sequel