Suggestions by @michael21
10,363 suggestions
Hailee Steinfeld
as Cynthia Peterson/Lydia Newlon in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Jack Champion
as Fred Jackson/Arthur Newlon in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Patrick Dempsey
as Eric Newlon in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Rick Hoffman
as Thomas in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Piper Rubio
as Liz Newlon in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Evangeline Lilly
as Eleanor in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
John Krasinski
as Daniel in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Jack Black
as Rudolph Newlon in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Zendaya Coleman
as Amelia Black in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Bella Thorne
as Taylor Ross in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Lia McHugh
as Joanne Barnes in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Jeremy Allen White
as Ethan Cross in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Yasmin Finney
as Liv Chen in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Landry Bender
as Brittany Cooper in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Austin Butler
as Luke Chase in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Ariana Greenblatt
as Michelle O'Neil in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Tye Sheridan
as Casper George in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Paris Berelc
as Chloe Grace in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Gaten Matarazzo
as Hector Fernandez in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)
Noah Jupe
as Noah Harper in Thanksgiving 2 (my version)