Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo

Parker Posey

as Carla Nelson in American Horror Story Road Trip

David Tennant

as Dr. Rudy Vincent in American Horror Story Recast

Tilly Keeper

as Sharon Tate in American Horror Story Recast

Judi Dench

as Miriam Meed in American Horror Story Recast

Keke Palmer

as Dinah Stevens in American Horror Story Recast

Ella Purnell

as Mallory in American Horror Story Recast

Carrie Coon

as Madelyn in American Horror Story Recast

W. Earl Brown

as Phil in American Horror Story Recast

Ashley Benson

as Hannah in American Horror Story Recast

Uma Thurman

as The Fist in American Horror Story Recast

Michael B. Jordan

as Andre Stevens in American Horror Story Recast

Nico Santos

as Baldwin Pennypacker in American Horror Story Recast

Parker Posey

as Samantha Crowe in American Horror Story Recast

Kate Winslet

as Coco St. Pierre Vanderbilt in American Horror Story Recast

Seth Rogen

as Mutt Nutter in American Horror Story Recast

Julie Walters

as Bubbles McGee in American Horror Story Recast

Jesse Eisenberg

as Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast

Gugu Mbatha-Raw

as Dr. Donna Chambers in American Horror Story Recast

Shay Mitchell

as Helen in American Horror Story Recast

Brandon Spink

as Eddie in American Horror Story Recast