Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo

Zachary Gordon

as AJ Ward in American Horror Story Tis The Season

Kate Mara

as Niamh Peterson-Burgess in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Ice Spice

as Alysha Solis in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Rose Byrne

as Nurse Maya Burke in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Dermot Mulroney

as Charles Simmons in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Cara Delevingne

as Penny Archer in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Madison Iseman

as Valentina West in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Laura Harrier

as Tina Freeman in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Cleopatra Coleman

as Leah Freeman in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Aubrey Plaza

as Liana Hernandez in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Billie Lourd

as Natalia Robinson in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Jacob Elordi

as Olly Yates in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Frances Conroy

as Karen Robles in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Matt Bomer

as Alvin Craig in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Violet McGraw

as Bianca Mcconnell in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Rachel Zegler

as Roxanna Hernandez in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Margot Robbie

as Nicole Hanson in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Finn Wittrock

as James Owen in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Mikey Madison

as Holly Yates in American Horror Story Mountain Resort

Danny DeVito

as Dr. Thomas Mullen in American Horror Story Mountain Resort