Suggestions by @mephilesthedark

Toad (Keegan-Michael Key)

as Keegan-Michael Key in Ranking Characters By Actor

Prince Edward

as James Marsden in Ranking Characters By Actor

Tom Wachowski

as James Marsden in Ranking Characters By Actor

Cyclops (Fox Universe)

as James Marsden in Ranking Characters By Actor

Gambit (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

as Channing Tatum in Ranking Characters By Actor

Chicha

as Wendie Malick in Ranking Characters By Actor

Elizabeth Swann

as Kiera Knightly in Ranking Characters By Actor

Petey the cat

as Pete Davidson in Ranking Characters By Actor

Sheriff Bronson Stone

as Patrick Warburton in Ranking Characters By Actor

Wolf W. Wolf

as Patrick Warburton in Ranking Characters By Actor

Blag (The Wild)

as Patrick Warburton in Ranking Characters By Actor

Flynn (Skylanders)

as Patrick Warburton in Ranking Characters By Actor

Frankenstein (DC)

as David Harbour in Ranking Characters By Actor

Candyman (Daniel Robitaille)

as Yahya Abdul-Mateen II in Ranking Characters By Actor

Pistol Pete Whipple

as Cary Elwes in Ranking Characters By Actor

Charlie (Finding Dory)

as Stanley Tucci in Ranking Characters By Actor

Megatron (TF One)

as Brian Tyree Henry in Ranking Characters By Actor

Scourge (Transformers Cinematic Universe)

as Peter Dinklage in Ranking Characters By Actor

The Missing Link

as Will Arnett in Ranking Characters By Actor

Conquest (Invincible)

as Jeffrey Dean Morgan in Ranking Characters By Actor