Suggestions by @mbdavis

Manish Dayal

as Marty in Local Woman Missing

Camila Morrone

as Shelby in Local Woman Missing

Camilla Morrone

as Shelby in Local Woman Missing

Zach Roerig

as Jason in Local Woman Missing

Allison Williams

as Carmen in Local Woman Missing

Gabriella Wilde

as Cassandra in Local Woman Missing

Alexandra Shipp

as Bea in Local Woman Missing

Suki Waterhouse

as Kate in Local Woman Missing

Joshua Bassett

as Leo in Local Woman Missing

Joshua Jackson

as Josh in Local Woman Missing

Karen Gillan

as Meredith in Local Woman Missing

Sadie Sink

as Delilah in Local Woman Missing

Ben Rosenfield

as Silas in Writers And Lovers

Mike Vogel

as Oscar in Writers And Lovers

Dylan O'Brien

as Silas in Writers And Lovers

Glen Powell

as Adam in Writers And Lovers

Michiel Huisman

as Oscar in Writers And Lovers

Evan Jonigkeit

as Marcus in Writers And Lovers

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Harry in Writers And Lovers

Melissa Barrera

as Muriel in Writers And Lovers