Suggestions by @matthewweikert
3,302 suggestions
Leslie Carrara-Rudolph
as Abby Cadabby in Matthew's Easter Party
Kevin Clash
as Elmo in Matthew's Easter Party
Pablo (The Backyardigans)
as Little Boy in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Kenickie
as Calloway's Conscience in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Matthew Weikert
as Royal Priest in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Tasha (The Backyardigans)
as Bearded Lady in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Lips
as Orchestra Pit 6 in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Zoot
as Orchestra Pit 5 in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Animal
as Orchestra Pit 4 in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Janice
as Orchestra Pit 3 in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Floyd Pepper
as Orchestra Pit 2 in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Dr. Teeth
as Orchestra Pit in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Elmo (Sesame Street)
as Choreographer in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Prairie Dawn
as Composer in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Betty Rizzo
as On the Spot News Reporter in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Squidward Tentacles
as TV Newsman in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Sheldon J. Plankton
as Self-Destruct Voice in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Shaker
as Guard 8 in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Big Al
as Guard 7 in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Liver Lips McGrowl
as Guard 6 in Be My Valentine, Matthew