Suggestions by @matthewweikert
3,302 suggestions
Matt Vogel
as Floyd in Tales of a Sixth Grade Muppet
Bill Barretta
as Dr.Teeth in Tales of a Sixth Grade Muppet
Frank Oz
as Fozzie in Tales of a Sixth Grade Muppet
Jerry Nelson
as Lew Zealand in Tales of a Sixth Grade Muppet
Michael Dorn
as Sandman in Matthew's Christmas Carol
William Shatner
as Tooth Fairy in Matthew's Christmas Carol
James Caan
as Father Time in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Martin Short
as Jack Frost in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Aisha Tyler
as Mother Nature in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Harvey Fierstein
as Easter Bunny in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Kevin Pollak
as Cupid in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Matthew Weikert
as Writer in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Corwin C. Tuggles
as Tyrone (singing) in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Reginald Davis, Jr.
as Tyrone in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Charles Durning
as Santa Claus in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Lewis Black
as Anger in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Phyllis Smith
as Sadness in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Amy Poehler
as Joy in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Bill Hader
as Fear in Matthew's Christmas Carol
Mindy Kaling
as Disgust in Matthew's Christmas Carol