Suggestions by @matthewweikert
3,302 suggestions
David Rudman
as Janice in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Matt Vogel
as Floyd Pepper in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Alice Cooper
as Alice Cooper in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Cheryl Ladd
as Cheryl Ladd in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Steve Martin
as Steve Martin in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Raquel Welch
as Raquel Welch in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Elton John
as Elton John in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Sylvester Stallone
as Sylvester Stallone in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Liza Minnelli
as Liza Minelli in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
William Shatner
as Tooth Fairy in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Aisha Tyler
as Mother Nature in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Jamia Simone Nash
as Uniqua (singing) in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
LaShawn Jefferies
as Uniqua in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Corwin C. Tuggles
as Tyrone (singing) in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Reginald Davis, Jr.
as Tyrone in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Clancy Brown
as Mr. Eugene Krabs in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Carolyn Lawrence
as Sandy Cheeks in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Rodger Bumpass
as Squidward Tentacles in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Bill Fagerbakke
as Patrick Star in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Tom Kenny
as SpongeBob SquarePants in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party